The Replay with Nick, Nolan & Sarge

Every week, we’ll recap sports from across the Kenai Peninsula—EVERY GAME. EVERY MEET. Catch interviews with coaches and athletes, both local and from across the state. And hey, we may even sneak in some hot takes on what’s happening in college and pro sports.

Episodes

Jun 3, 2026

51 min

STATE CHAMPIONS!! The Soldotna Boys Soccer team is back on top of the mountain. AND, the Kenai Girls are state runners-up! A great year for Peninsula soccer squads. The crew recaps it all in this week's show.
 
An up and down year for baseball and softball conference tournaments, but 2 peninsula teams still managed to qualify for state. In baseball, the best game at state may be in the first round and feature the Soldotna Stars.
 
A significant change was handed down to 3A & 4A state basketball by ASAA. Make sure not to miss our deep dive into this change.

Jun 3, 2026

51 min

May 27, 2026

51 min

The Lady Stars are Region III Champions AGAIN! Soldotna High School Athletic Director and Head Track & Field Coach Phil Leck joins the show to preview this weekend's state track meet in Anchorage. 
 
State Soccer is this weekend, and we have TWO #1 seeds from the peninsula heading to the Valley. What potential matchups are we most excited about? Tune in to find out!
 
Also, what would it take for you to run a marathon? How about 890 of them?? Catch our conversation about one exceptional Irishman who has done just that. 

May 27, 2026

51 min

May 13, 2026

52 min

SNOW IN MAY?? Well, that's inconvenient. Nick, Nolan, and Sarge dive into the wacky weather over the weekend and how it impacted Peninsula sports. 
 
SOHI and Kenai Baseball have a chance to take a stranglehold on conference standings in the coming weeks. Who are they playing, and what do they need to do? Catch our conversation about it in this week's show.
 
On the pitch, Soldotna girls' soccer is taking Alaska by storm this season. How good are they? And where do the rest of our peninsula soccer teams stack up in the latest RPI? The guys break it all down!

May 13, 2026

52 min

May 6, 2026

53 min

Homer High School graduate and athlete, former D1 NCAA football player, and now candidate for Alaska governor, Adam Crum joins the show to talk about the role high school and college sports played in his career as a student and an athlete. 
 
The crew recaps everything that went down over the last week in Peninsula sports. Routs on the baseball diamond, a TON of softball games in the Mat Su Valley, rivalry soccer games, and big time performances on the track! Catch all the details this week on The Replay!

May 6, 2026

53 min

Apr 29, 2026

51 min

Track and Field on the Peninsula is on another level right now! The Soldotna Varsity squad headed to Boise, Idaho, for the Bandana Invitational and delivered some sensational performances. Back on the Kenai, the Kardinals dominated the Kenai Invitational.
 
The Soldotna Stars baseball team was ot deterred by the inclement weather hampering the Buddy Dale Tournament in the Mat Su Valley, and orchestrated impromptu games when tournament games were canceled. And then they delivered, winning every game of the weekend in dominant fashion.
 
Who won the draft? Was it Sarge's Raaaiiiiidahs? Did Nick's Dolphins reach beyond their historical draft mediocrity? Tune in and catch our thoughts!

Apr 29, 2026

51 min

Apr 22, 2026

52 min

The Soldotna Stars head to the Buddy Dale Tournament in Wasilla this weekend, where they will face a number of Division 1 contenders. Head Coach Ken Gibson and a crew of his seniors joins the show to talk about their success in the Sitka tournament earlier this season, as well as their expectations for D1 play.
Peninsula Athletes were dominant at the Homer Invitational track meet over the weekend (spoiler alert, one school from this area won SIX of the eight varsity relays!). The guys recap that track meet and dive into the track and field season.
And the NFL Draft is this weekend. Most are calling this year's draft a weak one, but what does that even mean? Catch our conversation about it and our thoughts on the top draft prospects.

Apr 22, 2026

52 min

Apr 15, 2026

55 min

What a start to the season for Soldotna Baseball. The Stars took care of business in SE Alaska over the weekend, and The Replay is here to break it all down.
Powerlifter and professional thrower Danny Autrey from Kenai River Wolfpack Rugby joins the show to talk track and field, and the guys dive into some amazing track & field state records that are so good, they may never be broken.

Apr 15, 2026

55 min

Apr 8, 2026

49 min

This week on The Replay: Is Dan Hurley one of the all-time great college basketball coaches? Nick and Nolan dive into that and more, recapping the college basketball national title game between Michigan and UConn. The Alaska Association of Basketball Coaches Senior All-Star game is this weekend. It's one last chance for the best senior ball players in the state to showcase their talents before wrapping up their high school careers. Nick and Nolan will both be there. Tune in to find out who else will be there and how you can catch the action!
 
The Soldotna Stars Division 1 baseball journey begins this week as they head to Sitka for an annual Southeast tournament. The guys chat about the success of spring sports on the Peninsula and what we can expect from the Stars and other teams this season.

Apr 8, 2026

49 min

Apr 1, 2026

1 hr 3 min

With the Alaska State Basketball tournaments wrapped up, the only thing left for high school basketball is the Alaska Association of Basketball Coaches annual awards, and boy did the Peninsula shine in those! Coach Jake Songer of KCHS girls' basketball joins Nick and Nolan to talk about the landslide of awards raked in by Peninsula athletes and coaches this year.
 
Also, March is Madness. The guys talk the UCONN v Duke Elite 8 game because what kind of sports show would we be if we left THAT bombshell alone??
 
Finally, SOHI athletes went to Anchorage for the Big C Relays (yes, track has already started), and put up some amazing performances. Tune in to catch our recap of that as well as a peek ahead at spring sports. 

Apr 1, 2026

1 hr 3 min

Mar 25, 2026

1 hr 45 sec

The 3OT 3A Boys Championship between Barrow and Mt Edgecumbe was an instant classic, and one of the greatest games of any sport, since the '93 Trajan Langdon East v Bartlett 3OT thriller. The guys break it down, and then they chat with Edgecumbe head coach (and Kenai Central grad) Marshall Vest. 
Speaking of champs, Jacob Strausbaugh, now a DII national wrestling champion, joins the show to talk about his amazing run to a title as a freshman at the University of Mary. What a packed show! Don't miss it!

Mar 25, 2026

1 hr 45 sec

Copyright 2024 All rights reserved.

Podcast Powered By Podbean

Version: 20241125